Nutil

Spotting Health Quackery

How to identify dubious medical claims and protect yourself

Spotting Health Quackery

When health claims sound too good to be true, they usually are. Here's how to spot the warning signs.

The Placebo Effect Is Real

Before dismissing everything, understand that placebos actually work through real mechanisms[1]—they cause measurable physical changes.

Placeboⓘ

Noceboⓘ

Healthcare professionals across Europe recognize placebo and nocebo effects[4].

Key insight: Feeling better after a treatment doesn't prove the treatment works. Placebo effects, natural recovery, and regression to the mean can all create the illusion of effectiveness.

Red Flags for Quackery

### 1. Miracle Cure Claims

Watch for:

Real medicine acknowledges limitations. Nothing works for everyone. Real treatments have known failure rates and side effects.

### 2. "Ancient Wisdom" or "Natural" Appeal

Natural fallacyⓘ

"Ancient wisdom" is also suspect—our ancestors also believed in bloodletting, trepanning, and mercury cures. Age doesn't equal validity.

### 3. Conspiracy Thinking

Classic quackery claims:

If something actually worked, the "conspiracy" would need to include millions of doctors, researchers, and regulators worldwide—including in countries with no stake in Western pharmaceutical profits.

### 4. Testimonials Instead of Evidence

Personal stories are psychologically compelling but scientifically weak[6].

Why testimonials aren't evidence:

### 5. Attacking Conventional Medicine

Legitimate alternatives complement conventional care; quackery often demands you choose.

Warning: Never stop prescribed medications based on advice from alternative practitioners without consulting your doctor.

Warning phrases:

Why People Believe

People who use alternative medicine aren't anti-science[7].

Common justifications for using alternative medicine[8]:

These are understandable motivations, even when the chosen solutions don't work.

Specific Quackery to Know

### Homeopathy

Belief in homeopathy correlates with lower trust in science and vaccines[9].

Homeopathyⓘ

Why studies sometimes seem positive:

Even in well-designed trials, homeopathy equals placebo[11]

### Acupuncture

More complex than homeopathy—some real effects, but often overstated.

Acupuncture has real effects on sensory perception[12]

The problem: "sham" acupuncture (needles in random places, or non-penetrating needles) often works as well as "real" acupuncture. This suggests the effect may be from:

### "Detox" Products

Your liver and kidneys already detoxify your body. Products claiming to "remove toxins" rarely specify what toxins, how they're measured, or how the product removes them.

If you've been poisoned, you need emergency medicine—not a juice cleanse.

### Supplements Without Evidence

The supplement industry is poorly regulated. Claims like "supports immune function" don't require proof because they avoid claiming to treat disease.

Warning signs:

How to Evaluate Health Claims

### Ask These Questions

1. What's the evidence? Look for randomized controlled trials, not testimonials

2. Who's making the claim? Financial interest? Credentials?

3. Is it published? In peer-reviewed journals or just press releases?

4. Has it been replicated? One study proves nothing

5. What do experts say? Major medical organizations?

6. What are the risks? Everything has risks—if they claim none, be suspicious

### Red Flag Checklist

When Alternative Approaches Help

Not all complementary approaches are quackery:

Likely helpful:

May help, needs more research:

No good evidence:

Talking to Someone Using Quackery

Scientists sometimes come across as dismissive[13]

Do:

Don't:

People turn to quackery for reasons. Understanding those reasons matters more than winning arguments.

Protect Yourself

1. Be skeptical of certainty — Real medicine acknowledges uncertainty

2. Check sources — Peer-reviewed research, not blogs or social media

3. Consult professionals — Ask your doctor about any supplement or treatment

4. Watch your wallet — Desperation makes us vulnerable to expensive "cures"

5. If it works, they'd prove it — Effective treatments can demonstrate effectiveness in trials

---

References

  1. ['Benedetti F', 'Frisaldi E', 'Piedimonte A'] (2015). Different Placebos, Different Mechanisms, Different Outcomes: Lessons for Clinical Trials. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  2. ['Evers AWM', 'Colloca L'] (2024). Placebo and nocebo in clinical practice: An online cross-sectional survey of healthcare professionals from European countries on views, practices and training needs. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  3. ['Ngai CSB', 'Singh RG'] (2023). Navigating persuasive strategies in online health misinformation: An interview study with older adults on misinformation management. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  4. ['Lewith G', 'Stuart B', 'Chalder T', 'Brien S'] (2013). Incommensurable Worldviews? Is Public Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines Incompatible with Support for Science and Conventional Medicine?. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  5. ['Bostrom K', 'Bremander A'] (2018). Justifications for using complementary and alternative medicine reported by persons with musculoskeletal conditions: A narrative literature synthesis. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  6. ['Fasce A', 'Adrián-Ventura J'] (2023). Medical decision making beyond evidence: Correlates of belief in complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and homeopathy. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  7. ['Macías-Cortés EC', 'Llanes-González L', 'Aguilar-Faisal L', 'Asbun-Bojalil J'] (2015). Individualized Homeopathic Treatment and Fluoxetine for Moderate to Severe Depression in Peri- and Postmenopausal Women (HOMDEP-MENOP Study): A Randomized, Double-Dummy, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  8. ['Li J', 'Zhang J', 'Shang H', 'Xue J', 'Liang J', 'Zhang D'] (2014). Effects of Acupuncture on Sensory Perception: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. PLOS ONE. [DOI]
  9. ['Dong C', 'Chen X', 'Wang Y'] (2023). Scientists' deficit perception of the public impedes their behavioral intentions to correct misinformation. PLOS ONE. [DOI]